Files
accounted/supabase/migrations/20260621130000_api_keys_rotation_grace.sql
T
Jakob Wennberg 5078b4e02d fix(mcp): grace window + idempotent refresh-token replay for OAuth (#710) (#714)
* fix(mcp): grace window + idempotent refresh-token replay for OAuth (#710)

OAuth refresh rotated BOTH the refresh token and the access key in one
zero-grace CAS. Claude Code's MCP OAuth client fails to persist the rotated
refresh token (or fires concurrent refreshes), re-presents the stale one, the
CAS matches 0 rows, and the grant dies with invalid_grant — forcing a full
re-authorization roughly every 60s in a loop. Regression from #392.

Keep rotation (RFC 9700 §4.14.2 requires it for public clients) but add a
bounded grace window with idempotent replay, atomic in one SECURITY DEFINER RPC:

- Migration adds previous_key_hash / previous_refresh_token_hash (+ *_expires_at)
  shadow columns. validate_and_increment_api_key accepts the current OR an
  unexpired previous key_hash, with the rate-limit increment keyed off the
  resolved row id.
- New rotate_mcp_refresh_token RPC: rotated | replayed | reuse_revoked |
  revoked | invalid. In-grace replay re-issues a fresh pair and slides the
  window so an actively-refreshing client that cannot persist the rotated token
  keeps working; reuse after the window revokes the grant family (RFC 9700
  4.14.2 reuse detection preserved).
- The refresh grant now calls the one RPC, closing the old SELECT-then-CAS
  TOCTOU gap.

All previous_* columns default NULL, so existing keys are unaffected and the
RPC return shape is unchanged (callers untouched).

Tests: rewired the token-route unit tests to the RPC and replaced the test that
codified the bug with a #710 regression (in-grace replay returns 200, not 400);
added tests/pg/mcp-oauth-rotation-grace.pg.test.ts (grace accept/expire,
revoke-never-graced, rotate->demote, idempotent replay, reuse-after-grace->revoke).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* ci: retrigger checks for #714

No code change — re-running CI. The Supabase Preview check fails on a
pre-existing main-branch migration-history drift ("Remote migration versions
not found in local migrations directory"), not this PR; pg-real (full migration
replay) passes.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-06-12 10:05:10 +02:00

234 lines
9.7 KiB
PL/PgSQL

-- Rotation grace + idempotent refresh for MCP OAuth (issue #710).
--
-- Problem: handleRefreshTokenGrant rotated BOTH the refresh token and the
-- access key in one CAS-guarded UPDATE with zero grace. A client (Claude Code
-- CLI) that fails to persist the rotated refresh token — or fires concurrent
-- refreshes — presents the just-superseded token, the CAS matches 0 rows, and
-- the grant dies with `invalid_grant`, forcing a full re-auth roughly every
-- ~60s in an endless loop.
--
-- Fix: keep rotation (RFC 9700 §4.14.2 requires public-client refresh tokens to
-- be rotated or sender-constrained) but add a bounded GRACE WINDOW with
-- idempotent replay:
-- * The just-superseded access key (`previous_key_hash`) and refresh token
-- (`previous_refresh_token_hash`) stay valid for a grace window.
-- * Presenting the previous refresh token WITHIN the window re-issues a fresh
-- pair (idempotent replay) and slides the window, so an actively-refreshing
-- client that cannot persist the rotated token is never stranded.
-- * Presenting it AFTER the window is a reuse/breach signal → the grant is
-- revoked (reuse detection preserved).
-- All four shadow columns default NULL → existing keys are unaffected. Because
-- the shadow columns live on the SAME row gated by `revoked_at IS NULL`, a
-- single `revoked_at` UPDATE atomically kills the current AND both previous
-- credentials (RFC 9700 grant-family revocation, no fan-out).
ALTER TABLE public.api_keys
ADD COLUMN IF NOT EXISTS previous_key_hash text,
ADD COLUMN IF NOT EXISTS previous_key_expires_at timestamptz,
ADD COLUMN IF NOT EXISTS previous_refresh_token_hash text,
ADD COLUMN IF NOT EXISTS previous_refresh_expires_at timestamptz;
-- Partial-UNIQUE on each previous hash: lookups are point reads and two rows can
-- never claim the same previous hash. Separate from the current-hash indexes so
-- current + previous coexist on one row without collision.
CREATE UNIQUE INDEX IF NOT EXISTS idx_api_keys_previous_key_hash
ON public.api_keys (previous_key_hash)
WHERE previous_key_hash IS NOT NULL;
CREATE UNIQUE INDEX IF NOT EXISTS idx_api_keys_previous_refresh_token_hash
ON public.api_keys (previous_refresh_token_hash)
WHERE previous_refresh_token_hash IS NOT NULL;
-- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-- validate_and_increment_api_key: accept the current key_hash OR an unexpired
-- previous_key_hash (access-token grace). Identical return shape, so callers in
-- lib/auth/api-keys.ts are unaffected. The rate-limit UPDATE is now keyed off
-- the resolved row id (not p_key_hash) so a grace-hash hit still increments.
-- (CREATE OR REPLACE cannot keep an identical signature across a body change
-- cleanly here; DROP+CREATE mirrors the pattern in 20260512162506.)
-- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
DROP FUNCTION IF EXISTS public.validate_and_increment_api_key(text);
CREATE FUNCTION public.validate_and_increment_api_key(p_key_hash text)
RETURNS TABLE(
user_id uuid,
company_id uuid,
api_key_id uuid,
api_key_name text,
rate_limited boolean,
scopes text[],
mode text
)
LANGUAGE plpgsql SECURITY DEFINER AS $$
DECLARE
v_id uuid;
v_user_id uuid;
v_company_id uuid;
v_api_key_name text;
v_rate_limit_rpm integer;
v_request_count integer;
v_window_start timestamptz;
v_scopes text[];
v_mode text;
BEGIN
-- Match the live key_hash, OR a previous (just-rotated) key_hash that is still
-- inside its grace window. Both gated by revoked_at IS NULL.
SELECT ak.id, ak.user_id, ak.company_id, ak.name,
ak.rate_limit_rpm, ak.request_count, ak.rate_limit_window_start, ak.scopes, ak.mode
INTO v_id, v_user_id, v_company_id, v_api_key_name,
v_rate_limit_rpm, v_request_count, v_window_start, v_scopes, v_mode
FROM public.api_keys ak
WHERE ak.revoked_at IS NULL
AND (
ak.key_hash = p_key_hash
OR (
ak.previous_key_hash = p_key_hash
AND ak.previous_key_expires_at IS NOT NULL
AND ak.previous_key_expires_at > now()
)
)
FOR UPDATE;
IF v_id IS NULL THEN
RETURN; -- no live match (incl. expired grace) → caller returns 401, as before
END IF;
-- Reset the rate-limit window if it is unset or older than one minute.
IF v_window_start IS NULL OR v_window_start < now() - interval '1 minute' THEN
UPDATE public.api_keys
SET request_count = 1,
rate_limit_window_start = now(),
last_used_at = now()
WHERE id = v_id;
RETURN QUERY SELECT v_user_id, v_company_id, v_id, v_api_key_name, false, v_scopes, v_mode;
RETURN;
END IF;
IF v_request_count >= v_rate_limit_rpm THEN
RETURN QUERY SELECT v_user_id, v_company_id, v_id, v_api_key_name, true, v_scopes, v_mode;
RETURN;
END IF;
UPDATE public.api_keys
SET request_count = request_count + 1,
last_used_at = now()
WHERE id = v_id;
RETURN QUERY SELECT v_user_id, v_company_id, v_id, v_api_key_name, false, v_scopes, v_mode;
END;
$$;
-- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
-- rotate_mcp_refresh_token: atomic lookup + rotate + demote + idempotent replay
-- for the OAuth refresh_token grant. Replaces the JS SELECT-then-CAS (which had
-- a TOCTOU gap). The caller pre-generates the candidate new credentials; this
-- function decides whether to use them.
--
-- Outcomes:
-- 'rotated' presented hash = current refresh token → normal rotation;
-- current creds demoted to previous_* with a grace window.
-- 'replayed' presented hash = an unexpired previous refresh token → the
-- client retried / mis-persisted the rotated token (or a
-- concurrent sibling already rotated). Re-issue a fresh pair
-- and SLIDE the grace window so an actively-refreshing client
-- keeps working. The previous hash is preserved (not chained)
-- so a truly idle gap longer than the window still trips reuse.
-- 'reuse_revoked' presented hash = an EXPIRED previous refresh token → reuse
-- after grace = breach (RFC 9700 §4.14.2) → revoke the grant.
-- 'revoked' the matched grant is already revoked.
-- 'invalid' no matching grant.
-- ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
CREATE OR REPLACE FUNCTION public.rotate_mcp_refresh_token(
p_presented_hash text,
p_new_refresh_hash text,
p_new_key_hash text,
p_new_key_prefix text,
p_grace_seconds integer
)
RETURNS TABLE(outcome text, scopes text[])
LANGUAGE plpgsql SECURITY DEFINER AS $$
DECLARE
v_id uuid;
v_revoked timestamptz;
v_scopes text[];
v_cur_key_hash text;
v_prev_refresh_expires timestamptz;
v_match text;
BEGIN
-- Current refresh token?
SELECT ak.id, ak.revoked_at, ak.scopes, ak.key_hash
INTO v_id, v_revoked, v_scopes, v_cur_key_hash
FROM public.api_keys ak
WHERE ak.refresh_token_hash = p_presented_hash
FOR UPDATE;
IF v_id IS NOT NULL THEN
v_match := 'current';
ELSE
-- Previous (just-rotated) refresh token?
SELECT ak.id, ak.revoked_at, ak.scopes, ak.key_hash, ak.previous_refresh_expires_at
INTO v_id, v_revoked, v_scopes, v_cur_key_hash, v_prev_refresh_expires
FROM public.api_keys ak
WHERE ak.previous_refresh_token_hash = p_presented_hash
FOR UPDATE;
IF v_id IS NOT NULL THEN
v_match := 'previous';
END IF;
END IF;
IF v_id IS NULL THEN
RETURN QUERY SELECT 'invalid'::text, NULL::text[];
RETURN;
END IF;
IF v_revoked IS NOT NULL THEN
RETURN QUERY SELECT 'revoked'::text, NULL::text[];
RETURN;
END IF;
IF v_match = 'current' THEN
-- Normal rotation. Demote the consumed refresh token and the superseded
-- access key to previous_* with a grace window, then promote the new pair.
UPDATE public.api_keys
SET previous_refresh_token_hash = p_presented_hash,
previous_refresh_expires_at = now() + make_interval(secs => p_grace_seconds),
previous_key_hash = v_cur_key_hash,
previous_key_expires_at = now() + make_interval(secs => p_grace_seconds),
refresh_token_hash = p_new_refresh_hash,
key_hash = p_new_key_hash,
key_prefix = p_new_key_prefix
WHERE id = v_id;
RETURN QUERY SELECT 'rotated'::text, v_scopes;
RETURN;
END IF;
-- v_match = 'previous'
IF v_prev_refresh_expires IS NOT NULL AND v_prev_refresh_expires > now() THEN
-- Idempotent in-grace replay: a retried / mis-persisted / concurrent
-- refresh. Re-issue a fresh current pair and SLIDE the grace window. The
-- previous refresh hash stays the presented one (no chaining), so reuse of
-- the original token after an idle gap longer than the window still trips
-- reuse detection below.
UPDATE public.api_keys
SET previous_refresh_expires_at = now() + make_interval(secs => p_grace_seconds),
previous_key_hash = v_cur_key_hash,
previous_key_expires_at = now() + make_interval(secs => p_grace_seconds),
refresh_token_hash = p_new_refresh_hash,
key_hash = p_new_key_hash,
key_prefix = p_new_key_prefix
WHERE id = v_id;
RETURN QUERY SELECT 'replayed'::text, v_scopes;
RETURN;
END IF;
-- Reuse of a previous refresh token AFTER its grace window = breach signal.
-- Revoke the grant family (single row → kills current + both previous creds).
UPDATE public.api_keys
SET revoked_at = now()
WHERE id = v_id;
RETURN QUERY SELECT 'reuse_revoked'::text, NULL::text[];
END;
$$;
NOTIFY pgrst, 'reload schema';