Files
accounted/extensions/general/mcp-server
10bbfb9d79 fix(mcp): make agent failures diagnosable from the log, not just from the source (#2087)
* fix(mcp): make agent failures diagnosable from the log, not just from the source

Mining event_log for mcp.tool_called: VALIDATION_ERROR ran at about one a day
until 2026-08-25, then jumped to a hundred a day and stayed there. One
integration's gnubok_get_kpi_report has been refused 604 times over seven days
and is still failing.

The cause is the unknown-parameter guard from #1856, which is correct and
stays. The caller is even told precisely what is wrong: getStructuredError puts
"Unknown parameter "x" for <tool>. Valid parameters: ..." into message_en,
which the agent receives.

What was broken is what we recorded about it. Two things, both cheap:

- Telemetry logged only message_sv, which for VALIDATION_ERROR is the registry
  default "Förfrågan innehåller ogiltiga uppgifter." and names neither the
  parameter nor the tool. A seven-day outage was indistinguishable from a typo,
  and the cause was only findable by reading the dispatcher source. errorDetail
  now carries message_en, stored only when it differs from errorMessage, so the
  many domain failures whose message_sv is already the specific text cost
  nothing extra.
- errorKind said 'company_access_denied' for all 604, because the arg guard
  throws inside the company-routing try. That is an active misdirection: it
  sends triage looking for a tenancy bug that does not exist. Exactly two
  things in that block raise VALIDATION_ERROR, the unknown-parameter guard and
  a malformed company_id, and neither is a permissions failure, so they now log
  as 'invalid_arguments'.

Tests reproduce the production call shape and were verified to fail when either
fix is reverted.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* test(mcp): derive the telemetry payload type from the event contract

Two review findings, both valid.

The local ToolCalledPayload interface was a hand-maintained duplicate that
omitted sessionId and half the errorKind union. That is not cosmetic: it is why
errorDetail could be added to the emitter and to lib/events/types.ts while the
test file type-checked against a stale shape. Deriving it from
EventPayload<'mcp.tool_called'> removes the drift.

The null-detail assertion was also conditional, so it would have passed on a
wrong-but-present value. Replaced with two determinate cases: a scope denial
carries both languages without duplicating either, and the unknown-tool exit,
which supplies no diagnostic, stores null.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* test(mcp): pin the scope name in the diagnostic assertion

'A different string' passes on any placeholder. The reason errorDetail is worth
storing is that it names what the caller lacks, so assert that.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: Jakob Wennberg <311770904+jakobwennberg-oss@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-08-31 22:24:28 +02:00
..
2026-07-24 15:03:50 +02:00
2026-07-24 15:03:50 +02:00

Accounted MCP server

JSON-RPC 2.0 server exposing the Accounted bookkeeping engine to MCP clients (Claude Desktop, Claude Code, etc.). Endpoint: /api/extensions/ext/mcp-server/mcp. Add ?tool_namespace=accounted for the Accounted tool names. Requests without it retain the legacy Gnubok namespace. OAuth and stdio bridges live alongside the API surface: see app/api/mcp-oauth/, packages/accounted-mcp/, and the compatibility package in packages/gnubok-mcp/.

Tool authoring contract

Enforced by tests in __tests__/: these are not style preferences, they're guard rails.

  1. additionalProperties: false on every inputSchema. Guarded by strict-schemas.test.ts. Forces clear rejections on hallucinated fields instead of silent ignores.
  2. Descriptions ≤ 280 chars. Guarded by output-schema.test.ts. No Args: / Returns: / Examples: prose: those belong in JSON Schema. Use agent-native hints ("Use to…", "Call X first", "HIGH risk").
  3. Staged-operation envelope for write tools: outputSchema: STAGED_OPERATION_SCHEMA (server.ts). Fields: staged, risk_level, actor, message, preview, period_status?, next?. The staged: true boolean is the explicit completion signal; agents must not infer completion from prose. Do NOT introduce a parallel { success, shouldContinue, output } envelope.
  4. period_status threading: any tool that ties to a fiscal-period-bound date (categorize, mark paid, create voucher, correct/reverse entry, approve supplier invoice) passes dateForPeriodCheck to stagePendingOperation. Response then includes period_status: { period_id, status: open|locked|closed, lock_date } so widgets and agents disable writes without round-trips.
  5. Scope mapping: every new tool needs an entry in lib/auth/api-keys.ts TOOL_SCOPE_MAP. Missing entries default to deny.
  6. Tests for new write tools: add staging-gate coverage to __tests__/voucher-tools.test.ts (or a sibling) plus executor coverage to lib/pending-operations/__tests__/voucher-executors.test.ts if the tool stages a new operation_type.

Determinism / cache stability

Tool definitions (name, description, inputSchema, outputSchema, annotations) are declared as static object literals at module load: no timestamps, no UUIDs, no Date/Math.random in the definition layer. This makes the tools/list JSON payload byte-stable across requests, which lets agent-side prompt caches stay warm. Do not introduce per-request non-determinism into the definitions block. Anything time-bound or random belongs inside execute().

For internal Anthropic API usage (the SDK is called from lib/ai/provider.ts and lib/ai/services/anthropic-family.ts; features such as extensions/general/invoice-inbox/lib/extract-invoice-fields.ts go through getAiService() in lib/ai rather than the SDK directly): annotate stable prefixes with cache_control: { type: 'ephemeral' } and log usage.cache_read_input_tokens for hit-ratio observability. The 1h TTL from the agent-native API plan (item 10) requires the direct Anthropic API; Accounted's Bedrock path defaults to a shorter TTL.

Payload-size watchdog

payload-size.bench.test.ts enforces a tools/list JSON payload ceiling. If the test fires, the right answer is rarely "raise the ceiling". Instead, trim descriptions or set specialized wide tools to catalogVisibility: 'search'. Those tools remain discoverable with full schemas through gnubok_search_tools and callable through tools/call on the wire without bloating the default catalog. Claude.ai only calls tools present in tools/list, so a tool that a user or a skill must call directly stays in the default catalog.

Where things live

  • server.ts: the tools array + JSON-RPC dispatcher
  • tool-result.ts: withNext(), toToolError() response helpers
  • resources/: read-only Accounted:// URIs, registered in resources/index.ts: company/current, period/active, recent-activity, capabilities, attention, chart-of-accounts, settings/vat-treatments, booking-templates, ledger/context, reconciliation/summary
  • widgets/: inline HTML widgets (receipt-matcher, vat-review, pending-operations)
  • prompts/: slash-command-style prompts
  • skills/: domain-knowledge skill bodies served via gnubok_load_skill
  • public-tools.ts: lazy authentication (issue #1814). ANONYMOUS_METHODS (initialize, ping, tools/prompts/resources listing) and the three PUBLIC_TOOLS (gnubok_search_tools, gnubok_list_skills, gnubok_load_skill) answer without credentials, rate-limited per truncated IP; every other tools/call gets a transport-level 401 + WWW-Authenticate from handleMcpRequest in server.ts, which is the challenge clients turn into their Connect prompt
  • tasks.ts: MCP Tasks extension (io.modelcontextprotocol/tasks): durable handles for long-running tool calls, rows in mcp_tasks (service-role writes only)
  • origin-guard.ts: Origin-header validation on the Streamable HTTP endpoint (DNS-rebinding defence required by the MCP spec)
  • staging-pii-guard.ts: refuses a plaintext personnummer in staged pending_operations params/preview, so every staging tool inherits the encrypt-at-staging rule
  • tool-namespace.ts: ?tool_namespace=accounted handling (accounted_* aliases for the canonical gnubok_* ids)
  • __tests__/: strictness guards + per-tool coverage