{ "prompt": "BI-P017", "claim": "Every bypass attempt, executed directly against a live ClickHouse as the tenant's restricted user WITH THE STATEMENT GUARD REMOVED, fails to return a foreign-tenant row, an ungranted-table row, or server metadata.", "clickhouse_version": "24.8.14.39", "recorded_at": "2026-09-07T01:15:43.364Z", "base_table_rows_both_tenants": 100, "tenant_view_rows_alpha": 50, "attempts_total": 64, "attempts_that_leaked": 0, "legitimate_statements_that_succeeded": 10, "legitimate_statements_total": 10, "attempts": [ { "id": "cross-catalog-direct", "goal": "read the other tenant's catalog", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: catalog \"t_beta_sql\" is not readable by this session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT(customer, amount, event_time)" }, { "id": "cross-catalog-union", "goal": "union in the other tenant", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: catalog \"t_beta_sql\" is not readable by this session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT(customer) ON t_beta_sql.sales." }, { "id": "cross-catalog-subquery", "goal": "subquery on the other tenant", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: catalog \"t_beta_sql\" is not readable by this session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT for at least one column on t_b" }, { "id": "cross-catalog-join", "goal": "join the other tenant", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: catalog \"t_beta_sql\" is not readable by this session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT(customer) ON t_beta_sql.sales." }, { "id": "cross-catalog-cte", "goal": "hide the other tenant in a CTE", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: catalog \"t_beta_sql\" is not readable by this session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT(customer) ON t_beta_sql.sales." }, { "id": "cross-catalog-quoted", "goal": "quote the identifier to dodge the scan", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: catalog \"t_beta_sql\" is not readable by this session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT(customer, amount, event_time)" }, { "id": "cross-catalog-backtick", "goal": "backtick the identifier", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: catalog \"t_beta_sql\" is not readable by this session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT(customer, amount, event_time)" }, { "id": "base-table-direct", "goal": "read the shared base table, which holds every tenant", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: catalog \"opt_analytics\" is not readable by this session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT(tenant_id, project_id, dataset" }, { "id": "base-table-in-cte", "goal": "base table behind a CTE", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: catalog \"opt_analytics\" is not readable by this session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT(tenant_id) ON opt_analytics.op" }, { "id": "base-table-union", "goal": "union the base table in", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: catalog \"opt_analytics\" is not readable by this session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT(tenant_id) ON opt_analytics.op" }, { "id": "system-tables", "goal": "enumerate every table on the server", "engine_http_status": 200, "engine_clickhouse_code": null, "engine_succeeded": true, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: \"SYSTEM\" is not permitted in a read-only analyst session", "engine_response_head": "opt_analytics events opt_analytics sales t_alpha_sql events t_alpha_sql sales" }, { "id": "system-columns", "goal": "enumerate columns", "engine_http_status": 200, "engine_clickhouse_code": null, "engine_succeeded": true, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: \"SYSTEM\" is not permitted in a read-only analyst session", "engine_response_head": "opt_analytics events tenant_id String 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 \\N \\N \\N \\N \\N opt_analytics events customer String 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 \\N \\N \\N \\N \\N opt_analytics e" }, { "id": "system-users", "goal": "enumerate users", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: \"SYSTEM\" is not permitted in a read-only analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT(name, id, storage, auth_type," }, { "id": "system-processes", "goal": "read other tenants' running queries", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: \"SYSTEM\" is not permitted in a read-only analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT(query) ON system.processes. (A" }, { "id": "system-query-log", "goal": "read other tenants' statement text out of the log", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: \"SYSTEM\" is not permitted in a read-only analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT(query) ON system.query_log. (A" }, { "id": "information-schema", "goal": "metadata via the ANSI schema", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: catalog \"information_schema\" is not readable by this session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT(table_catalog, table_schema, t" }, { "id": "one-table", "goal": "the always-present one-row table", "engine_http_status": 200, "engine_clickhouse_code": null, "engine_succeeded": true, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: \"SYSTEM\" is not permitted in a read-only analyst session", "engine_response_head": "0" }, { "id": "tf-url", "goal": "exfiltrate over HTTP", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: function \"url\" is not permitted in an analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant CREATE TEMPORARY TABLE, URL ON *.*. (" }, { "id": "tf-file", "goal": "read the server filesystem", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: function \"file\" is not permitted in an analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant CREATE TEMPORARY TABLE, FILE ON *.*." }, { "id": "tf-s3", "goal": "read object storage directly", "engine_http_status": 400, "engine_clickhouse_code": "36", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: function \"s3\" is not permitted in an analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 36. DB::Exception: Bucket name length is out of bounds in virtual hosted style S3 URI: 'b' (http://minio/b/%2A). (BAD_ARGUMENTS) (version 24.8.14.39 (offi" }, { "id": "tf-remote", "goal": "query another ClickHouse server", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: function \"remote\" is not permitted in an analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant CREATE TEMPORARY TABLE, REMOTE ON *.*" }, { "id": "tf-mysql", "goal": "reach an external database", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: function \"mysql\" is not permitted in an analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant CREATE TEMPORARY TABLE, MYSQL ON *.*." }, { "id": "tf-executable", "goal": "run a program", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: function \"executable\" is not permitted in an analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant CREATE TEMPORARY TABLE ON *.*. (ACCES" }, { "id": "tf-numbers", "goal": "a CPU bomb that touches no table", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "158", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: function \"numbers_mt\" is not permitted in an analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 158. DB::Exception: Limit for rows (controlled by 'max_rows_to_read' setting) exceeded, max rows: 100.00 thousand, current rows: 100.00 billion. (TOO_MANY" }, { "id": "tf-generate", "goal": "unbounded synthetic scan", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "158", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: function \"generaterandom\" is not permitted in an analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 158. DB::Exception: Limit for rows or bytes to read exceeded, max rows: 100.00 thousand, current rows: 315.79 thousand: While executing GenerateRandom. (T" }, { "id": "tf-merge", "goal": "merge() glob across a database", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: function \"merge\" is not permitted in an analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant CREATE TEMPORARY TABLE ON *.*. (ACCES" }, { "id": "tf-cluster", "goal": "fan out across the cluster", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: function \"cluster\" is not permitted in an analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant REMOTE ON *.*. (ACCESS_DENIED) (versi" }, { "id": "tf-view", "goal": "wrap a subquery in view()", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: function \"view\" is not permitted in an analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT(tenant_id, project_id, dataset" }, { "id": "fn-dictget", "goal": "read a dictionary, bypassing table grants", "engine_http_status": 400, "engine_clickhouse_code": "36", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: function \"dictget\" is not permitted in an analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 36. DB::Exception: Dictionary (`d`) not found: In scope SELECT dictGet('d', 'v', toUInt64(1)) AS x FROM t_alpha_sql.sales. (BAD_ARGUMENTS) (version 24.8.1" }, { "id": "stacked-drop", "goal": "stacked statement", "engine_http_status": 400, "engine_clickhouse_code": "62", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: multiple statements are not allowed in an analyst SQL session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 62. DB::Exception: Syntax error (Multi-statements are not allowed): failed at position 32 (end of query): ; DROP TABLE opt_analytics.opt_analytics_event ." }, { "id": "insert", "goal": "write", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: analyst SQL sessions accept SELECT and WITH statements only", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant INSERT(customer, amount, event_time)" }, { "id": "insert-select", "goal": "write from a read", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: analyst SQL sessions accept SELECT and WITH statements only", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant INSERT(customer, amount, event_time)" }, { "id": "alter-delete", "goal": "mutate", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: analyst SQL sessions accept SELECT and WITH statements only", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant ALTER DELETE ON opt_analytics.opt_ana" }, { "id": "create-view-escape", "goal": "create an unfiltered view to read later", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: analyst SQL sessions accept SELECT and WITH statements only", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant CREATE VIEW ON t_alpha_sql.escape. (A" }, { "id": "grant-self", "goal": "grant itself more", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: analyst SQL sessions accept SELECT and WITH statements only", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT ON opt_analytics.* WITH GRANT" }, { "id": "system-command", "goal": "operate the server", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: analyst SQL sessions accept SELECT and WITH statements only", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SYSTEM RELOAD DICTIONARY ON *.*. (ACC" }, { "id": "kill-query", "goal": "kill another tenant's query", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: analyst SQL sessions accept SELECT and WITH statements only", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT(query_id, user, query) ON syst" }, { "id": "truncate", "goal": "destroy data", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: analyst SQL sessions accept SELECT and WITH statements only", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant TRUNCATE ON t_alpha_sql.sales. (ACCES" }, { "id": "optimize", "goal": "trigger heavy background work", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: analyst SQL sessions accept SELECT and WITH statements only", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant OPTIMIZE ON opt_analytics.opt_analyti" }, { "id": "outfile", "goal": "write to the filesystem", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "358", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: \"OUTFILE\" is not permitted in a read-only analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 358. DB::Exception: INTO OUTFILE is not allowed. (INTO_OUTFILE_NOT_ALLOWED) (version 24.8.14.39 (official build))" }, { "id": "settings-raise-rows", "goal": "raise max_rows_to_read", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "164", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: \"SETTINGS\" is not permitted in a read-only analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 164. DB::Exception: Cannot modify 'max_rows_to_read' setting in readonly mode. (READONLY) (version 24.8.14.39 (official build))" }, { "id": "settings-readonly-off", "goal": "turn readonly off", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "164", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: \"SETTINGS\" is not permitted in a read-only analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 164. DB::Exception: Cannot modify 'readonly' setting in readonly mode. (READONLY) (version 24.8.14.39 (official build))" }, { "id": "set-statement", "goal": "SET before the query", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "164", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: analyst SQL sessions accept SELECT and WITH statements only", "engine_response_head": "Code: 164. DB::Exception: Cannot modify 'max_execution_time' setting in readonly mode. (READONLY) (version 24.8.14.39 (official build))" }, { "id": "format-override", "goal": "choose the wire format", "engine_http_status": 200, "engine_clickhouse_code": null, "engine_succeeded": true, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: \"FORMAT\" is not permitted in a read-only analyst session", "engine_response_head": "\u00032\bcustomer\u0006String ALPHA_ROW_0 ALPHA_ROW_1 ALPHA_ROW_2 ALPHA_ROW_3 ALPHA_ROW_4 ALPHA_ROW_5 ALPHA_ROW_6 ALPHA_ROW_7 ALPHA_ROW_8 ALPHA_ROW_9 ALPHA_ROW_10 ALPHA_RO" }, { "id": "comment-split-name", "goal": "hide a catalog boundary behind a comment", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: unqualified table \"opt_analytics\" — an analyst statement must name t_alpha_sql., or a CTE it defined itself", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT(tenant_id, project_id, dataset" }, { "id": "comment-line-hide", "goal": "hide the tail after a -- comment", "engine_http_status": 200, "engine_clickhouse_code": null, "engine_succeeded": true, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: \"SYSTEM\" is not permitted in a read-only analyst session", "engine_response_head": "ALPHA_ROW_0 ALPHA_ROW_1 ALPHA_ROW_2 ALPHA_ROW_3 ALPHA_ROW_4 ALPHA_ROW_5 ALPHA_ROW_6 ALPHA_ROW_7 ALPHA_ROW_8 ALPHA_ROW_9 ALPHA_ROW_10 ALPHA_ROW_11 ALPHA_ROW_12 A" }, { "id": "comment-hash-hide", "goal": "hide the tail after a # comment", "engine_http_status": 200, "engine_clickhouse_code": null, "engine_succeeded": true, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: \"SYSTEM\" is not permitted in a read-only analyst session", "engine_response_head": "ALPHA_ROW_0 ALPHA_ROW_1 ALPHA_ROW_2 ALPHA_ROW_3 ALPHA_ROW_4 ALPHA_ROW_5 ALPHA_ROW_6 ALPHA_ROW_7 ALPHA_ROW_8 ALPHA_ROW_9 ALPHA_ROW_10 ALPHA_ROW_11 ALPHA_ROW_12 A" }, { "id": "unterminated-comment", "goal": "run off the end of a comment", "engine_http_status": 400, "engine_clickhouse_code": "62", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [INVALID_REQUEST] 0pt.analytics.sql: unterminated block comment", "engine_response_head": "Code: 62. DB::Exception: Syntax error: failed at position 33 ('/* x '): /* x . Multiline comment is not closed: '/* x '. (SYNTAX_ERROR) (version 24.8.14.39 (off" }, { "id": "unterminated-string", "goal": "run off the end of a literal", "engine_http_status": 400, "engine_clickhouse_code": "62", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [INVALID_REQUEST] 0pt.analytics.sql: unterminated string literal", "engine_response_head": "Code: 62. DB::Exception: Syntax error: failed at position 50 (''x '): 'x . Single quoted string is not closed: ''x '. (SYNTAX_ERROR) (version 24.8.14.39 (offici" }, { "id": "unicode-homoglyph", "goal": "cyrillic homoglyph inside the catalog name", "engine_http_status": 400, "engine_clickhouse_code": "62", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: statement contains a disallowed character (U+0430) outside a string literal", "engine_response_head": "Code: 62. DB::Exception: Syntax error: failed at position 17 ('�'): аlpha_sql.sales . Unrecognized token: '�'. (SYNTAX_ERROR) (version 24.8.14.39 (official buil" }, { "id": "zero-width", "goal": "zero-width space inside a reserved catalog name", "engine_http_status": 400, "engine_clickhouse_code": "62", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: statement contains a disallowed character (U+200B) outside a string literal", "engine_response_head": "Code: 62. DB::Exception: Syntax error: failed at position 24 ('.'): .tables . Expected one of: FINAL, SAMPLE, table, table function, subquery or list of joined" }, { "id": "nul-byte", "goal": "NUL truncation between two halves of a statement", "engine_http_status": 400, "engine_clickhouse_code": "62", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: statement contains a disallowed character (U+0000) outside a string literal", "engine_response_head": "Code: 62. DB::Exception: Syntax error: failed at position 40 ('\u0000'): \u0000 UNION ALL SELECT name FROM system.tables . Unrecognized token: '\u0000'. (SYNTAX_ERROR) (versio" }, { "id": "case-mixing", "goal": "mixed case keywords and names", "engine_http_status": 404, "engine_clickhouse_code": "81", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: \"SYSTEM\" is not permitted in a read-only analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 81. DB::Exception: Database SyStEm does not exist. Maybe you meant system?. (UNKNOWN_DATABASE) (version 24.8.14.39 (official build))" }, { "id": "whitespace-newlines", "goal": "newlines and tabs between tokens", "engine_http_status": 200, "engine_clickhouse_code": null, "engine_succeeded": true, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: \"SYSTEM\" is not permitted in a read-only analyst session", "engine_response_head": "opt_analytics events 204f5e8f-9134-417f-b7f5-569500c15059 MergeTree 0 ['/var/lib/clickhouse/store/204/204f5e8f-9134-417f-b7f5-569500c15059/'] /var/lib/clickhous" }, { "id": "describe-subquery", "goal": "DESCRIBE a base table from inside a subquery, where the FROM-scan sees only a paren", "engine_http_status": 400, "engine_clickhouse_code": "62", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: DESCRIBE is not permitted in a read-only analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 62. DB::Exception: Syntax error: failed at position 16 ('DESCRIBE'): DESCRIBE TABLE opt_analytics.opt_analytics_event) . Expected one of: SELECT query, po" }, { "id": "desc-subquery-short", "goal": "the same, using the DESC abbreviation", "engine_http_status": 400, "engine_clickhouse_code": "62", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: DESCRIBE is not permitted in a read-only analyst session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 62. DB::Exception: Syntax error: failed at position 16 ('DESC'): DESC TABLE opt_analytics.opt_analytics_event) . Expected one of: SELECT query, possibly w" }, { "id": "current-user", "goal": "identify the session's ClickHouse principal", "engine_http_status": 200, "engine_clickhouse_code": null, "engine_succeeded": true, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: function \"currentuser\" is not permitted in an analyst session", "engine_response_head": "t_alpha_sql_user t_alpha_sql_user t_alpha_sql_user t_alpha_sql_user t_alpha_sql_user t_alpha_sql_user t_alpha_sql_user t_alpha_sql_user t_alpha_sql_user t_alpha" }, { "id": "three-part-name", "goal": "a three-part name", "engine_http_status": 400, "engine_clickhouse_code": "62", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: \"a.b.c\" is not a valid . reference", "engine_response_head": "Code: 62. DB::Exception: Syntax error: failed at position 21 (end of query): . Expected one of: ParserArrayOfJSONIdentifierDelimiter, token sequence, OpeningSqu" }, { "id": "unqualified-table", "goal": "unqualified name resolved by the connection's default database", "engine_http_status": 404, "engine_clickhouse_code": "60", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: unqualified table \"opt_analytics_event\" — an analyst statement must name t_alpha_sql., or a CTE it defined itself", "engine_response_head": "Code: 60. DB::Exception: Unknown table expression identifier 'opt_analytics_event' in scope SELECT * FROM opt_analytics_event. (UNKNOWN_TABLE) (version 24.8.14." }, { "id": "cte-shadow", "goal": "shadow a legitimate name with a CTE while also reading the real base table", "engine_http_status": 500, "engine_clickhouse_code": "497", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: catalog \"opt_analytics\" is not readable by this session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 497. DB::Exception: t_alpha_sql_user: Not enough privileges. To execute this query, it's necessary to have the grant SELECT for at least one column on opt" }, { "id": "no-from", "goal": "a statement that reads no table at all", "engine_http_status": 200, "engine_clickhouse_code": null, "engine_succeeded": true, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: statement references no readable object in the tenant catalog", "engine_response_head": "1" }, { "id": "object-not-granted", "goal": "an object in the right catalog that the session was not given", "engine_http_status": 404, "engine_clickhouse_code": "60", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "refused: [AUTHORIZATION_DENIED] 0pt.analytics.sql: object \"t_alpha_sql.secret_ledger\" is not readable by this session", "engine_response_head": "Code: 60. DB::Exception: Unknown table expression identifier 't_alpha_sql.secret_ledger' in scope SELECT * FROM t_alpha_sql.secret_ledger. (UNKNOWN_TABLE) (vers" }, { "id": "hidden-tenant-column", "goal": "select the tenant column the view does not project", "engine_http_status": 404, "engine_clickhouse_code": "47", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "admitted", "engine_response_head": "Code: 47. DB::Exception: Unknown expression identifier 'tenant_id' in scope SELECT tenant_id FROM t_alpha_sql.sales. (UNKNOWN_IDENTIFIER) (version 24.8.14.39 (o" }, { "id": "hidden-column-star-then-filter", "goal": "filter on a column the view does not expose", "engine_http_status": 404, "engine_clickhouse_code": "47", "engine_succeeded": false, "leaked_foreign_tenant_row": false, "leaked_ungranted_table_row": false, "leaked_server_metadata": false, "guard_verdict_for_reference": "admitted", "engine_response_head": "Code: 47. DB::Exception: Unknown expression or function identifier 'tenant_id' in scope SELECT count() AS n FROM t_alpha_sql.sales WHERE tenant_id = 't_beta'. (" } ], "legitimate": [ { "id": "simple", "ok": true, "status": 200, "contains_beta_canary": false }, { "id": "aggregate", "ok": true, "status": 200, "contains_beta_canary": false }, { "id": "cte", "ok": true, "status": 200, "contains_beta_canary": false }, { "id": "self-join", "ok": true, "status": 200, "contains_beta_canary": false }, { "id": "literal-with-quotes", "ok": true, "status": 200, "contains_beta_canary": false }, { "id": "literal-containing-sql-text", "ok": true, "status": 200, "contains_beta_canary": false }, { "id": "comment-then-query", "ok": true, "status": 200, "contains_beta_canary": false }, { "id": "subquery", "ok": true, "status": 200, "contains_beta_canary": false }, { "id": "union-own-catalog", "ok": true, "status": 200, "contains_beta_canary": false }, { "id": "trailing-semicolon", "ok": true, "status": 200, "contains_beta_canary": false } ] }